Abstract
Background: Idiopathic talipes equinovarus (clubfoot) is a congenital deformity treated initially by the Ponseti method, but in cases of relapse, tibialis anterior tendon transfer (TATT) is commonly used. A complication of TATT is the development of ‘Hallux extensus’ deformity, characterised by hyperextension of the great toe at the metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ). This deformity’s functional impact has not been systematically assessed. Objective: To measure and evaluate the occurrence of cock up great toe deformity following TATT surgery in recurrent talipes equinovarus patients. The study also aims to introduce a functional test, the ‘Newcastle test’, to identify this deformity reliably. Methods: This study involved four patients who had undergone TATT for relapsed clubfoot. Patients were assessed for active ankle dorsiflexion and MTPJ angles using goniometry. Measurements were taken with knees in extension and flexion to evaluate the impact of tendoachilles involvement. A functional ‘Newcastle test’ was also introduced to assess the deformity under weight-bearing conditions. The Newcastle sign was deemed positive if hyperextension at the MTPJ and a dorsal crease were observed during ankle dorsiflexion. Results: All patients with TATT demonstrated a positive Newcastle sign on the operated side. The average dorsiflexion in knee extension was lower on the TATT side (−0.75°) compared to the non‑TATT side (9°). The average MTPJ dorsiflexion angle was significantly greater on the TATT side (91.25°) compared to the non‑TATT side (45°). The Newcastle test consistently demonstrated the presence of the cock up deformity in the TATT-operated foot. Conclusion: The Newcastle test is a simple, reproducible functional test for identifying cock up great toe deformity following TATT in clubfoot patients. The study suggests that dorsiflexion weakness in the medial foot and posterior structural tightness may contribute to the deformity. Further biomechanical studies are recommended to refine tendon transfer techniques to prevent this complication and reduce the risk of long-term osteoarthritis in the MTPJ.
Keywords: Clubfoot, cock up great toe, Newcastle sign, tibialis anterior tendon transfer